Start scaling remotely with confidence — let us connect you with your next indispensable team member
Book Your Consultation

You Hired an Executive Assistant to Save Time. So Why Are You Now Doing Two People's Jobs?

Three common Executive Assistant recruitment mistakes that leave business leaders managing more, rather than delegating more.

A business owner hires an Executive Assistant (EA) to take day-to-day operational responsibilities off their plate. Two months later, they realise their working day has barely changed.

They're still managing their own workload, but now they're also checking their assistant's emails, chasing deadlines, approving minor decisions and explaining things they assumed wouldn't need explaining.

The salary is being paid. Tasks are being completed. Yet the promised time savings haven't materialised.

The paradox? The business owner hired someone to reduce their workload and ended up with another person to manage.

Often, the problem begins long before the assistant's first day. It starts with the recruitment process.

1

Why an Impressive CV Doesn't Necessarily Mean an Effective Executive Assistant

Consider two candidates for an Executive Assistant position.

The first has five years' experience supporting senior executives, is proficient in Excel, has organised business travel and understands professional etiquette.

The second has less experience but can structure complex tasks independently, clarify priorities and recommend solutions when circumstances change.

Who would you hire?

The answer depends on what the executive actually needs. But if the aim is to delegate complex operational responsibilities, years of experience alone are not enough.

Recruitment research supports this approach.

According to LinkedIn's Future of Recruiting 2025 report, 93% of surveyed talent acquisition professionals believe that accurately assessing candidates' skills is crucial to improving quality of hire.

The report also found that companies making greater use of skills-based candidate searches were 12% more likely to achieve a high quality of hire, according to LinkedIn's methodology. This is an observed association, not a guarantee for every recruitment decision.

In other words, experience matters. But it needs to be backed up by demonstrable capability.

2

Mistake No. 1: Looking for an All-Rounder Without Defining What Success Looks Like

"Executive Assistant required: excellent communicator, highly organised, adaptable, able to multitask and work under pressure."

These requirements appear in countless job descriptions. But what exactly should change once the new assistant joins?

✓ Free up 10 hours of the executive's working week by taking ownership of operational tasks.
✓ Coordinate external suppliers independently and keep projects on schedule.
✓ Manage business travel and meeting arrangements from start to finish.
✓ Reduce the number of routine decisions that need to reach the CEO.

These are measurable outcomes against which candidates can be assessed.

An executive who needs diary management and correspondence support requires a different skill set from someone looking for a trusted right-hand person to coordinate several business functions.

When the role is poorly defined, even a highly capable candidate can turn out to be the wrong hire.

3

Mistake No. 2: Testing Knowledge Instead of Independent Judgement

During an interview, a candidate confidently describes organising events, booking international travel and handling confidential information.

That sounds reassuring. But it doesn't necessarily reveal how they'll respond when plans unravel.

A practical scenario can be far more revealing:

"Your CEO has three important meetings tomorrow. One business partner wants to reschedule, another needs urgent approval on a set of documents, and the CEO will be unavailable for the next two hours. What would you do?"

A strong candidate may not produce a perfect answer immediately. What matters is how they approach the problem.

Can they identify priorities? Understand competing constraints? Make decisions within their authority? Recognise when an issue genuinely needs to be escalated?

These are the capabilities that determine whether an Executive Assistant will reduce an executive's workload or create additional supervision.

That's why effective Executive Assistant recruitment should include practical, scenario-based assessments rather than relying entirely on CVs and interviews.

4

Mistake No. 3: Cutting Recruitment Costs Without Considering the Cost of a Bad Hire

According to SHRM's 2025 Recruiting Benchmarking Report, the average cost per hire among the US organisations surveyed was $5,475 for non-executive positions and $35,879 for executive positions.

These are US recruitment benchmarks across different job categories, not UK-specific figures or estimates of the cost of hiring an Executive Assistant.

Nevertheless, they highlight an important point: recruitment consumes resources, even when a company manages the process internally.

An unsuccessful hire can create additional costs through management time, repeated interviews, onboarding another employee and disruption to day-to-day operations.

Comparing an in-house search with a specialist recruitment agency solely on the cost of advertising a vacancy therefore misses the bigger picture.

The more useful question isn't how cheaply you can recruit. It's what it takes to secure the right person for the role.

6

How to Tell Whether an Executive Assistant Will Actually Make Your Working Day Easier

Before making an offer, assess five essential qualities:

✓ Autonomy: Can the candidate take ownership of tasks without needing constant direction?

✓ Prioritisation: Can they distinguish between something that is urgent and something that genuinely matters?

✓ Communication: Can they work effectively with senior stakeholders, colleagues and external partners?

✓ Analytical thinking: Do they recommend solutions, or simply pass information along?

✓ Executive compatibility: Does their working style, pace and level of initiative suit the person they'll be supporting?

The final point is particularly important.

Some executives prefer detailed updates and regular approval points. Others expect their assistant to handle most operational matters independently.

The same Executive Assistant could thrive in one environment and struggle in the other.

Finding the right EA is therefore about more than identifying the most impressive CV. It's about matching an individual's capabilities, judgement and working style to the executive's responsibilities and expectations.

7

When Is It Worth Using a Specialist Executive Assistant Recruitment Agency?

According to SHRM's 2025 research, the median time to fill a vacancy among the US organisations surveyed was approximately six weeks, measured from the opening of a position to a candidate accepting an offer.

This is a general US recruitment benchmark, rather than a figure specific to Executive Assistant recruitment in the UK.

For a business owner, however, an extended hiring process can mean weeks of additional operational pressure.

Particularly when they are personally responsible for defining the role, reviewing applications, conducting interviews and assessing candidates' professional capabilities.

SMART AND TALENTED is an international recruitment agency specialising in Executive Assistants, Personal Assistants and professionals supporting business owners and senior executives.

Effective recruitment goes beyond reviewing experience. It requires a clear understanding of the executive's responsibilities, the level of autonomy expected, the competencies the role demands and the working relationship that needs to develop.

If you're looking for an Executive Assistant who can take genuine ownership of day-to-day responsibilities, start by defining what you want the role to achieve.
Подобрать ассистента
An excellent Executive Assistant won't necessarily eliminate every operational task from an executive's day. But the right hire can significantly reduce the number of decisions, interruptions and responsibilities requiring their direct involvement.

And that is the real purpose of hiring one.